During SSL/TLS handshake failures, you may notice a SChannel eventbeing logged in the System event logs. A closer looks provides that there is a number associated with these failure messages. The logging mechanism is a part of the SSL/TLS Alert Protocol. These alerts are used to notify peers of the normal and error conditions. The numbers especially, play a trivial role in understanding the problem/failure within the SSL/TLS handshake. SChannel logging may have to be enabled on the windows machines to get detailed SChannel messages. Please refer the following article to do so: http://support.microsoft.com/kb/260729
Below is an example of one such event:
Log Name: System
Source: Schannel
Date: x/xx/xxxx x:xx:xx
Event ID: 36887
Task Category: None
Level: Error
Keywords:
User: SYSTEM
Computer: xxxxxxx
Description: The following fatal alert was received: 47.
These warnings sometimes are very helpful in troubleshooting SSL related issues and provide important clues. However, there is not much documentation available on the description of the alert codes. These alert codes have been defined precisely in TLS/SSL RFC’s for all the existing protocol versions.
- RFC 5246 (TLS 1.2) -https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5246#appendix-A.3
- RFC 8446 (TLS 1.3) -https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc8446#appendix-B.2
The RFC has a definition for the various alert messages encountered during SSL/TLS handshake. Below is a snippet from the above RFC describing the various alert messages:
B.2. Alert Messages enum { warning(1), fatal(2), (255) } AlertLevel; enum { close_notify(0), unexpected_message(10), bad_record_mac(20), decryption_failed_RESERVED(21), record_overflow(22), decompression_failure_RESERVED(30), handshake_failure(40), no_certificate_RESERVED(41), bad_certificate(42), unsupported_certificate(43), certificate_revoked(44), certificate_expired(45), certificate_unknown(46), illegal_parameter(47), unknown_ca(48), access_denied(49), decode_error(50), decrypt_error(51), export_restriction_RESERVED(60), protocol_version(70), insufficient_security(71), internal_error(80), inappropriate_fallback(86), user_canceled(90), no_renegotiation_RESERVED(100), missing_extension(109), unsupported_extension(110), certificate_unobtainable_RESERVED(111), unrecognized_name(112), bad_certificate_status_response(113), bad_certificate_hash_value_RESERVED(114), unknown_psk_identity(115), certificate_required(116), no_application_protocol(120), (255) } AlertDescription; struct { AlertLevel level; AlertDescription description; } Alert;There is MSDN article which describes these messages more briefly. Here is the link: http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc783349%28v=ws.10%29.aspx. However, the article never mentions the alert codes while explaining the messages. For simplicity, I have created a simpler table combining both the MSDN documentation and the RFC for usability. Below is the table:
Alert Code | Alert Message | Description |
close_notify | Notifies the recipient that the sender will not send any more messages on this connection. | |
10 | unexpected_message | Received an inappropriate message This alert should never be observed in communication between proper implementations. This message is always fatal. |
20 | bad_record_mac | Received a record with an incorrect MAC. This message is always fatal. |
21 | decryption_failed | Decryption of a TLSCiphertext record is decrypted in an invalid way: either it was not an even multiple of the block length or its padding values, when checked, were not correct. This message is always fatal. |
22 | record_overflow | Received a TLSCiphertext record which had a length more than 2^14+2048 bytes, or a record decrypted to a TLSCompressed record with more than 2^14+1024 bytes. This message is always fatal. |
30 | decompression_failure | Received improper input, such as data that would expand to excessive length, from the decompression function. This message is always fatal. |
40 | handshake_failure | Indicates that the sender was unable to negotiate an acceptable set of security parameters given the options available. This is a fatal error. |
42 | bad_certificate | There is a problem with the certificate, for example, a certificate is corrupt, or a certificate contains signatures that cannot be verified. |
43 | unsupported_certificate | Received an unsupported certificate type. |
44 | certificate_revoked | Received a certificate that was revoked by its signer. |
45 | certificate_expired | Received a certificate has expired or is not currently valid. |
46 | certificate_unknown | An unspecified issue took place while processing the certificate that made it unacceptable. |
47 | illegal_parameter | Violated security parameters, such as a field in the handshake was out of range or inconsistent with other fields. This is always fatal. |
48 | unknown_ca | Received a valid certificate chain or partial chain, but the certificate was not accepted because the CA certificate could not be located or could not be matched with a known, trusted CA. This message is always fatal. |
49 | access_denied | Received a valid certificate, but when access control was applied, the sender did not proceed with negotiation. This message is always fatal. |
50 | decode_error | A message could not be decoded because some field was out of the specified range or the length of the message was incorrect. This message is always fatal. |
51 | decrypt_error | Failed handshake cryptographic operation, including being unable to correctly verify a signature, decrypt a key exchange, or validate a finished message. |
60 | export_restriction | Detected a negotiation that was not in compliance with export restrictions; for example, attempting to transfer a 1024 bit ephemeral RSA key for the RSA_EXPORT handshake method. This message is always fatal. |
70 | protocol_version | The protocol version the client attempted to negotiate is recognized, but not supported. For example, old protocol versions might be avoided for security reasons. This message is always fatal. |
71 | insufficient_security | Failed negotiation specifically because the server requires ciphers more secure than those supported by the client. Returned instead of handshake_failure. This message is always fatal. |
80 | internal_error | An internal error unrelated to the peer or the correctness of the protocol makes it impossible to continue, such as a memory allocation failure. The error is not related to protocol. This message is always fatal. |
90 | user_cancelled | Cancelled handshake for a reason that is unrelated to a protocol failure. If the user cancels an operation after the handshake is complete, just closing the connection by sending a close_notify is more appropriate. This alert should be followed by a close_notify. This message is generally a warning. |
100 | no_renegotiation | Sent by the client in response to a hello request or sent by the server in response to a client hello after initial handshaking. Either of these would normally lead to renegotiation; when that is not appropriate, the recipient should respond with this alert; at that point, the original requester can decide whether to proceed with the connection. One case where this would be appropriate would be where a server has spawned a process to satisfy a request; the process might receive security parameters (key length, authentication, and so on) at start-up and it might be difficult to communicate changes to these parameters after that point. This message is always a warning. |
255 | unsupported_extension |
There were few articles that I found while searching that contain additional alert codes. However, I don’t find these to be part of the RFC. Here is one: http://botan.randombit.net/doxygen/classBotan_1_1TLS_1_1Alert.html It includes additional alerts like 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115. You can browse the above link for further reading. Hope someone finds the above table useful. It may not help you in solving any issue but would provide useful pointers.
