Impossible Pie Recipe - The Recipe Critic (2024)

Don’t be fooled by the name, this impossible pie is one of the easiest pies you’ll ever make! Called “impossible” because it magically forms its own crust, you can have this pie ready for the oven in just 7 minutes. This pie is a classic for a reason- the creamy custard filling and crunchy topping are irresistible!

With the holidays coming up, pie recipes are definitely on my mind. We try to make at least one new pie flavor every year, and I think this impossible pie has made the menu! If you are looking for inspiration for this season’s pies, you’ve got to try my unique Caramel Apple Slab Pie or my famous classic Pumpkin Pie recipe. If you want to bring something a bit different to the table this fall season, be different with my Cherry Pie Bars– you won’t regret it!

Why is it Called Impossible Pie?

The Impossible Pie has been around for a long time! It is believed to be a very old Amish recipe, and may have been given the name “impossible” because it magically makes its own crust. The filling is a coconut custard (similar to a coconut cream pie) and as it bakes the coconut forms a lovely crunchy topping. After making this pie, I can see why it is a classic!

I love this recipe because it comes together in minutes, and is easy to bake. I think it’s also called “impossible” because it’s impossibly easy! You really just blend all of the ingredients in a blender, pour the batter in a pan (no, you don’t need a pie crust!) and bake! I like a topping on my coconut cream pie, so I also quickly whipped up some whipped cream. I never thought I could enjoy a coconut dessert more than my favorite Coconut Cream Cake, but this pie may have it beat!

Ingredients in Impossible Pie

My favorite thing about this recipe is this list of ingredients! It is so simple, and you probably already have these supplies in your fridge and pantry. I love how the simple desserts always end up becoming my favorites! See the recipe card below for exact measurements.

• Eggs: I always use large grade A eggs.
• Butter: I used unsalted in this recipe, and I would recommend you do too.
• Flour: All-purpose works the best in this recipe.
• Milk: Milk is necessary in this recipe because it gives it that creamy texture you need in a custard and helps the pie set up nicely.
• Granulated Sugar: I just used my pantry white granulated sugar for this recipe.
• Shredded Coconut: I used the sweetened kind because I love the flavor!
• Vanilla: Vanilla extract boosts the flavor of the milk and coconut, and really brings this pie to life!
• Nutmeg: Ground nutmeg is optional. I really like it in this pie because it gives it a warm holiday flavor, but you could easily leave it out.

How to Make Impossible Pie

These directions really couldn’t get any easier! It took me just 7 minutes to get this batter ready for the oven. I loved cutting into it and seeing the layers that separate while baking.

1. Preheat: Preheat the oven to 350℉ and grease a 9-10” pie dish.
2. Blend: Blend all the ingredients in the blender for 15 seconds, until well combined.
3. Bake: Pour the blended ingredients into the prepared pie pan and bake for 50-55 minutes, until the center of the pie is almost completely set and browned.
4. Cool: Allow the pie to cool to room temperature before chilling in the fridge for at least 2 hours before serving.