Chicken Enchilada Casserole (Easy Recipe) - 730 Sage Street (2024)

Chicken enchilada casserole is a family favorite meal that is so easy to make. Chicken, enchilada sauce and cheese are baked until it’s all golden brown and delicious.

Thischicken enchilada casserole recipeis the perfect family meal to enjoy without the fuss of rolling tortillas. If you like easy casserole meals, check out my collection of best zucchini casserole recipes.

🌟 Foolproof Chicken Enchilada Casserole

This recipe is based on the America's test kitchen enchiladas recipe.

Unlike most enchilada recipes that use corn or flour tortillas, thisenchilada casseroleis much easier to prepare without needing any high-carb tortillas and ready to eat in under 1 hour.

This easy chicken enchilada casserole is packed with delicious flavors of spicy green chilies, tomatoey red enchilada sauce, a delicious shredded chicken mixture, and lots of melty cheese.

It's made with half the ingredients found in most chicken enchiladas, making it budget-friendly and perfect for a busy weeknight meal. Plus, it can be prepared in advance for busy parents when time is limited. Another easy recipe to try is my chicken piccata and chicken spinach casserole.

Low carb chicken enchilada casseroleis versatile and can be made with fresh or cooked chicken, as well as making your own enchilada sauce or using canned from the grocery store to help save on prep time.

Nobody in your family will be able to resist this delicious meal for lunch or dinner, and it tastes even better the next day for meal prep.

🍽 Key Ingredients

This is a fairlysimple recipethat only needs essential pantry ingredients to prepare the mixture.. You can almost consider this abase recipeand change it up to your taste.

Chicken- We're using fresh boneless chicken breast for the chicken mixture.

Enchilada sauce- Use homemade enchilada sauce for a fresher taste or buy a canned variety from the store.

Cheese- For the chicken mixture, we're adding queso fresco because it's crumbly and salty, and for the cheese layers, a strong flavored cheese like cheddar cheese is required to add layers of flavor.

Chilies- Fresh or canned green chilies work fine with this recipe. Use as much as you like depending on how hot you want your enchiladas.

Herbs- A small amount of fresh cilantro mixed into the chicken mixture gives it an aromatic citrus flavor.

Substitutions

Chicken

You can use any leftover shredded chicken from a previous dinner or a rotisserie chicken instead of fresh chicken breast without changing the flavor.

Herbs

If you don't have any cilantro on hand, you could use freshly chopped parsley instead as a close substitution.

Cheese

Instead of queso fresco, you could opt for feta cheese as an equal substitute and Colby or Monterey jack cheese instead of cheddar for a similar flavor and melting qualities.

Remember, cheese is "all ok", so it is good to keep some of your favorites handy.

• Oaxaca: 10 points melting, 10+ elasticity
• Manchego: 10 points melting, 9 points elasticity
• Monterrey Jack: 9 points melting, 7 points elasticity

🔪 How to make

Chicken enchilada casserole is a delicious and super easy family dinner recipe to make in under one hour. The prep work is fast, and you can learn how to make it with my step-by-step instruction and helpful cooking tips.

Preparations

• Chop the cilantro and chilies.
• Pat chicken dry and season with salt and pepper.
• Preheat oven to 450 degrees Fahrenheit (220 degrees Celsius).

Cooking Instructions

Step 1

Combine the chicken and enchilada sauce in a medium saucepan & simmer for 10-15 minutes over medium-low heat.

Then flip the chicken over, cover, and cook for an additional 10-15 minutes until the chicken reaches 160-165 degrees with an instant-read thermometer.

Step 2

Remove chicken from pan and shred into bite-sized pieces. In a bowl, combine shredded chicken, the remaining enchilada sauce, queso fresco, chiles, and cilantro. Add salt and pepper if desired.

Step 3

Spray a square casserole dish with olive oil (or use a brush) and coat the entire bottom and sides. Evenly spread 1 cup of shredded cheddar cheese on the bottom of the dish. Add the chicken mixture.

Step 4

Then add the other cup of cheddar cheese on top. Cover with foil and bake for about 10 minutes.

Step 5

Remove foil to melt and brown cheese a bit for another 3 to 5 min. and voila. Mexican enchiladas of the day! Be careful when removing from the oven.

Step 6

Now slice some avocados, green onions, and chopped cilantro to garnish.

Once on the table, add a small bowl of sour cream to pour over your enchiladas. A delicious addition!

💭 Cooking Tips

Prepare ahead

If you're busy in the evenings and want to just pop a delicious recipe in the oven when you don't have time to prepare a meal, you could easily prepare this 1 day in advance and store it covered in the fridge, ready for baking.

Use block cheese

For better texture, buy the block of cheddar cheese rather than pre-shredded cheese. Packet shredded cheese from the grocery store comes with a coating that doesn't melt the same as freshly grated cheese, nor does it have the same smooth consistency.

⭐ Best Store-bought Enchilada Sauces

When it comes to enchiladas, the sauce is paramount. This single ingredient is the soul of all enchiladas. Here are the two best store-bought enchilada sauces!

Red Enchilada Sauce

The BEST red enchilada sauce is Rosarita enchilada sauce. This red tomato-based enchilada sauce dominates the kitchen and is loved by all. An authentic enchilada sauce with a hint of spice (mild heat) and is bold, zesty, and exactly what you'd expect.

Green Sauce

The BEST green enchilada sauce is Old El Paso's mild green enchilada sauce. This green tomato enchilada sauce beats other notable brands like Las Palmas and La Victoria. At the end of the day, this sauce has an authentic taste, with just a touch of heat, and packed with flavor.

Whatever enchilada sauce you choose, these proven red and green enchilada sauces have you covered.

📖 Recipe Variations

Thislow-carb chicken enchilada casseroleis versatile and can be made to suit everyone's taste buds while using this recipe. Try some of these additions to mix it up.

Protein

This recipe works just as well with ground beef, Italian sausage, ground turkey, or even shrimp.

Veggies

Feel free to add extra veggies like black beans, olives, chopped bell peppers, onion, and garlic.

Tortillas

Upgrade your chicken enchiladas with corn tortillas, and roll the chicken mixture inside. Use these classic america's test kitchen chicken enchiladasfor inspiration.

Sauce

Thisenchilada casseroleuses red enchilada sauce as it's slightly sweeter green enchilada sauce, but you can use whichever suits your taste buds. Both have the same flavor, just that the color is different and green chilies are hotter than the red variety.

🥗 What to serve with

Chicken enchilada casserole is a typical Mexican dish with other Mexican side dishes like rice, nachos, Pico de Gallo, or guacamole. Here are some easy taste creations to serve with these delicious enchiladas.

Tortillas

If you want to have some crunch and are not bothered about a few extra carbs with your meal, try out these crunchybaked tortilla stripsfor dipping in the melty cheese.

Rice

Mexican rice is a staple dish in any Mexican household. Although it can be tricky to replicate the same authentic taste, the same cannot be said about this low-carb option of fragrantcauliflower ricewith garlic, lime, onion, and cilantro.It's delicious and ready in just 15 minutes!

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

🧊 Storing and ♨️ Reheating

This easy chicken enchilada casserole is perfect for storing and eating the following day and tastes even better once the flavors infuse.

Fridge- Transfer any leftover chicken enchilada casserole to an airtight container, cover the baking dish in aluminum foil, and place it in the fridge for up to two days.

Freezer- Once thelow-carb chicken enchiladashave cooled completely, transfer the leftovers to a freezer container and freeze them for up to 3 months. Alternately, if you want to freeze unbaked chicken enchilada casserole, assemble the contents into a large aluminum tray, ready for baking.

Reheating- The quickest way to reheat leftover enchiladas is to microwave them for 1 to 2 minutes on full power until piping hot (may require longer for frozen leftovers. Or you can preheat an oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit and bake in the oven for 10-15 minutes until hot.

Save one of these amazing enchilada recipes for dinner! My favorite is the ground beef enchiladas.

Also check out my chicken bacon ranch casserole recipe that is ready in less than 40 minute! Same as my delicious copycat Longhorn parmesan crusted chicken recipe that will impress your family.

👪 Serving Size

This chicken enchilada casserole makes 5 servings and feeds 4 people. Given this is a casserole dish and super easy, you could double or triple this recipe to cater to more guests. I always make two casseroles to freeze one for the following week and save myself time.

So without further ado, below is the recipe. You won't even miss the tortilla!

📋 Recipe